Nicole Zoellner as Jenny Taylor(JT)

Mike Misko as Devlin Thornhill

Jessica Jaros as Miss Polly

Alexandra Pursglove as Lunamoona

Ben Littell as Pinkeye Joe

Valerie Long as Miss Grimm

Kelsey Merison as Suzy Spinkett

Russ Bailey as Narrator Ishmael

Nikki Tramposch as Cheffy

Dewayne Waite, Jr. as Scumbelly

Jacqui Farkas as Sapphire

Ben Canan as Mr. Green

Kory Grant as Native Leader

Jen Dorman as Holly

Danielle Storm as Girl #1/Student Ensemble

Sara Miller as Girl #2/Student Ensemble

Roy Gloeckl Pirate Ensemble

Kristen Scheidler as the Majorette

Alicia Crighton Native Ensemble

Sean Dotson Native Ensemble

Alex Kosuth Native Ensemble

Jenna Page Native Ensemble

Tim Snow Native Ensemble

Jen Fillo Student Ensemble

Steve Ruperto Student Ensemble

Alecia Trucco Student Ensemble

Rachel Zeolla Student Ensemble

Mark Zoellner Student Ensemble

Mrs. Mary Catley as herself

Seniors

JT & the Pirates

Lunamoona & the Island Natives

Devin & Miss Polly

Student Ensemble

Understudies